Overall Star Rankings

• 

  #1 - BillyShears has 239 stars from 44 users

  Final Fantasy VII - BillyShears's Most Popular Review
  80 - "Japanese people think all black people are Mr T. "
• 

  #2 - Ocelot has 87 stars from 29 users

  Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty - Ocelot's Most Popular Review
  100 - "almost every video game ever made only exists in the moment. you press buttons, get some pleasure stimulus in that reward center of your brain, and you forget about them until you play them again. Metal Gear Solid 2 shatters that convention -- it is a game that exists most thoroughly when it is not being played. it is gaming's essential text, a shining example of what's possible with the medium, and possibly the most prophetic text for the 21st century. sublime."
• 

  #3 - brickwall has 39 stars from 17 users

  Heavy Rain - brickwall's Most Popular Review
  60 - "When you take a step back and examine it, Heavy Rain is pretty laughable in a lot of ways but it does a lot right and I really do enjoy the novel concept of movie-games. I think the problem is that David Cage would make a terrible filmmaker."
• 

  #4 - Velvet Crowe has 37 stars from 17 users

  Heroes of Might and Magic 3 - Velvet Crowe's Most Popular Review
  98 - "One of the greatest games ever made. Has an incredible amount of depth, and the amount of scenarios and content is overwhelming. The only flaw it really has is that the game is a bit unbalanced - a lot of skills are mediocre or outright useless, and some factions are overwhelmingly better than others. Whatever you do, don't get the shitty "HD" edition on Steam. Buy the classic version of it on GOG."
• 

  #5 - Ytadel has 68 stars from 15 users

  Mario Kart: Double Dash - Ytadel's Most Popular Review
  8 - "Played this game absolutely obsessively back in the day and I’m more than happy to go back to it today. It could be argued as the best Mario Kart before Mario Kart 8. Some of the level design like DK Mountain and my favorite Rainbow Road are some of the best tracks in the entire Mario Kart franchise."
• 

  #6 - Obdurate has 30 stars from 15 users

  Fallout 76 - Obdurate's Most Popular Review
  55 - "The way it handles PvP is not actually bad because it eliminated a lot of griefing. However, there's also almost no tension so while I'm not sure how to fix that, there's not a lot of balance. Lacking human NPCs isn't the problem, it's lacking any real choice/consequences. Also, having a build limit takes away tools that are necessary for players to create their own stories (in the absence of real choices, that is needed), while also taking away desire to loot. It's passable with a friend."
• 

  #7 - hellboy76 has 21 stars from 15 users

  Spider Solitaire - hellboy76's Most Popular Review
  50 - "For you fancy fucks that can't just be happy with good ol' solitaire. "
• 

  #8 - mattorama12 has 20 stars from 14 users

  Final Fantasy VII - mattorama12's Most Popular Review
  90 - "If this game was just the Chocobo breeding and racing, it would still be one of the all-time greats."
• 

  #9 - CMonster has 33 stars from 12 users

  Yahtzee - CMonster's Most Popular Review
  2 - "This is the trash people associate with board games. We are in the middle of a board game Golden Age, the likes of which should have an impact on the future of gaming for decades. This should be taken out behind the barn and buried with Monopoly, Go Fish, and Sorry. Literally, thousands of better options than Yahtzee. "
• 

  #10 - Mentaculus has 28 stars from 12 users

  Super Mario Bros. 2 - Mentaculus's Most Popular Review
  85 - "In my best David Lynch voice: "There are secrets in the sand. I have found the dark universe, in a jar inside my dreams.""