How Do You Rank Your Movies?

[djross]

x

[Stewball]

I do not give a score above 90 unless I consider the movie a masterpiece. A score of 90 is still a superb movie, but in my mind there is somehow an important distinction between a masterpiece and a movie which is merely superb.

I agree. "Masterpiece" is the word I use for my 100's (90-99 Superb, 80-89 Outstanding).

[Ya SEE! There ya go, look what happens when ya got no standardization!!!]

[MmzHrrdb]

I just use numbers.

[AFlickering]

i give a mark out of 94 for the movie then roll a dice for the other 6

[Kortirion]

I first try and give it about a ballpark of how objectively good it is (which can be quite difficult), and then my subjective views about the movie can lower/raise the mark a bit. I would find that just subjective reviews of an art form such as cinema would be a poor idea, as one could rate a relatively entertaining but artistically shallow movie as high as a movie that is nearly transcendent of the art form.