2 games match Butter

Butterfly Soup is an indie visual novel by American developer Brianna Lei, released in 2017 (wikipedia.org).

A sequel to Butterfly Soup, a romantic sports visual novel about gay Asian-American teens playing baseball and falling in love. Set in the year 2009, the game switches between the perspectives of Diya, Noelle, Akarsha, and Min-seo as they navigate high school life in the San Francisco Bay Area. A 2-4 hour game, featuring memes. (itch.io)