ShogunRua wrote:Stewball wrote:I've previously said that Boyega's Finn was one dimensional. But this from John Dellingpole's review in Breitbat is a worthy expansion on my simple evaluation:
"Token. That’s what John Boyega’s character would be called if this were South Park. But he’s not. He’s called — oh, whatever, I forget and I’m not going to look it up.
"The tragic thing is that Boyega is actually one of Britain’s most charismatic young actors — check him out in the infinitely superior sci-fi movie Attack The Block. In The Force Awakens, however, Boyega has only two functions: 1.) be black 2.) be scaredy-cat and useless so that the Rey character (see above) can show how feisty and amazing and not-scared-of-anything and omnicompetent girls are by comparison.
"Director JJ Abrams has congratulated himself on the diversity of his casting. I’d say the creation of a character whose only real jobs are to be black and benignly lame has set the diversity clock back to the pre-Civil-War era."
Diversity....oh gag. Deliver me!
Boyega's character is not the only useless one. Han Solo is useless, too. So is Chewbacca. So are all the protagonists except the main one. That's because Daisy Ridley is an unstoppable, one-woman army/God who is better at everything than everyone despite no training or background.
1. an ace pilot who can outfly trained fighter pilots.
2. And she knows more about the engineering details of the Millennium Falcon than Han Solo.
3. And she is a crack shot even though she seems not to know where the safety on a handgun is.
4. And she saves Exhench one more time, using her knowledge of the mechanisms of an unfamiliar ship.
5. Then it turns out she has force powers like a Jedi, including visions of the future and past. She can resist mind-to-mind combat with Big Bad Sith, and even read his mind in the process. But, unlike Luke, she needs no training: she can do advanced mind-control techniques without a single lesson or even being told that such things are possible.
6. Hence, she can escape from the innermost dungeon of a Sith Lord fortress unaided.
7. And she can lightsaber fight without training against a man taller and stronger and trained in the art.
All those fall under the sardonic heading of omnicompetent, what. And not to strain at the argument overmuch, but imagine, for the sake of that argument, all the characters being strewn about are at a below average 5. Finn would be a 1.
And if you're reading Breitbart reviews, read John C Wright's review, too., where that list is taken from.
(Sigh) Out of the mouths of babes, or the Devil himself, the Truth is the Truth. If I was going to copyright it, I would have checked for plagiarism. But since this is the "net"....
Only so much time in the night & day y'know.
He's still flat as hell.
At least a rapist is a villain with some potential for at least an evil personality, as evident when he admits that he not only likes rape, but he's also into murder and arson, and is thus multi-dimensional. A wuss is a tree stump. (I know, I'm overusing the Hillary persona, but it's such a deep well I just can't help going back to it.)
