The Ten Most Polarizing Films of the 2010s
The word "polarizing" definitely comes to mind when looking back on the 2010s... this was the decade of Brexit, the Arab Spring, and the rise of social media. Society seemed to grow steadily more divided as the years progressed; politically, of course, but also just across the board. You either loved Pumpkin Spice Lattes and got excited about PSL season, or you hated them. You either thought the Minions were the cutest things ever, or went into a rage whenever you saw one. You saw either a blue and black dress, or a white and gold one. There was no in-between.
So perhaps it's no surprise that the 2010s were also ripe with contentious movies. We've taken a look through our catalog, and put together a list of the ten most polarizing films of this very polarizing decade. Take a look, and try not to get angry that someone else despised that film you loved. Or vice-versa!
How was this calculated?
For every film with at a certain number of ratings, we calculate the percentage of people who loved it (percentle greater than 75%) and hated it (less than 25%). The "contentiousness" score is the lower of those two percentiles.
Consider the most contentious possible scenario -- an equal number love and hate it, with nobody in between. That would be 50% - 0% - 50%, for a score of "50". Let's say another film has a "love/ambivalence/hate" ratio of "38/30/32". That gets a score of 32: still extremely polarizing!
But a movie that almost everyone hates? Let's say a breakdown of 4/35/61. That's a score of just 4, which means it's not very contentious at all.
#10.
Hard to Be a God
39.2% High
"Whether it had to be 3 hours is debatable, but there is no denying the singularity of German's vision; echoes of Tarkovsky, Fellini, Gilliam and even Welles are just that: echoes. German is marching to the insane beat of his own drum, pushing the cinematic form to an extreme to fashion an abstract sci-fi epic that feels both anachronistic and strikingly modern. The camera moves relentlessly, in long intricate takes, and the sense of world building is magnificent and completely transportive." - Yiannos
21.59% Low
"I have this rule always to finish a film once I've started watching it. Sometimes I hate that rule. It's not so much that I'll never get my time back (for this always applies). What's regrettable is the stupidity of stubbornly carrying on when it became apparent immediately that this particular film (no matter the considerable technical feats involved in its making) wouldn't, shall we say, tickle my fancy (I put storytelling first). Thus, I was quite needlessly in agony during three whole hours." - KasperL
#9.
The Souvenir
#8.
Mandy
25.69% High
"I can't even... okay, look. It's like this: If you eat the most goddamn delicious cheeseburger you've ever had in your life, what do you care that they replaced the cheese with LSD?" - DavidBlast
22.32% Low
"What in the ever-loving drug-fueled shock schlock did I just witness." - kem1
22.88% High
"Visceral, elemental and often very beautiful, this is a really impressionistic take on what it must have been really like to love in this time and place. Superb." - tinysausage
22.32% Low
"What a self indulgent piece of crap. It looks like a art students first venture into film making. If you like no dialogue and constant close up shots of hair go for it." - spaceace
#6.
Brimstone
22.58% High
"Brimstone is meticulously written and produced, has convincing visuals and an enthralling life story that does right to the western genre. While I feared amateurism and overreaching (and some here have apparently found it in bundles in this picture), I was genuinely happy with the production quality and wasn't for a moment distracted from the story. Although I read it to be "pretentious" here and there, to me it felt as more sincere than almost all high budget productions of late." - Guillaume
25.81% Low
"Laughably pretentious. An eleventh-rate director putting his last name on the title screen? A horribly botched attempt to amalgamate Das Weisse Band and Tarantino. Even Guy Pearce can only do so much with the blood-curdlingly corny lines he's given. The whole thing is painfully, heart-stoppingly immature, and feels like some sort of sick fulfillment of the director's perverted sexual fantasies. An arrogant, arrant abomination. 10/100 for Pearce." - McJohnson
#5.
Under the Skin
32.72% High
"A truly unique cinematic experience unlike any other. It was alienating at first (as it should be), but it haunted me for days until I came around to it. The astounding cinematography helped." - CinematicESP
22.74% Low
"There are people who like this movie and people who hate it. I'm in the latter portion. I hate this movie with a passion. It's so bad. Like, my god is it bad." - bjoernts
#4.
Les Misérables
22.89% High
"Superb, staggeringly emotional and well-wrought adaptation, masterfully brought to the screen by Hooper, successfully dodging most of the problems translating this very stagey show to the cinematic medium. Entire cast excels (though Crowe seems occasionally ill-at-ease and can't quite bring the required gravitas to his character), but Jackman, Cohen, Barks and especially Hathaway bring the knockout punches required to maximise the formiddable impact of the tunes and story. Viva Les Miserables!" - glumpy_99
23.8% Low
"Oh my God I hated this film. I kept waiting for it to get better, for some small glimmer of hope amongst the unrelenting suffering. I gave up after an hour and walked out. Even Anne Hathaway's song was anguishing. I usually like musicals but this was godawful. I really dislike films which try to manipulate your feelings. That's what this does." - Esmerodo
#3.
Spring Breakers
23.99% High
"This was absolutely amazing. Korine takes his usual style of direction and translates into a more mainstream context; the result is the most exhilarating film I've ever seen. Spring Breakers (which does include a plot, thanks Harmony!) hooked me in from the first frame. The film is so beautiful, I can still remember dozens of shots, embroidered with neon and accompanied by an equally incredible score. Acting can be a little weak, but it's not an issue. This is a film, man, engaging and gorgeous." - Dunder74
33.49% Low
"A pubescent teenager wet dream. Disgusting. No amount of cinematographic innovation (and still, this is debatable) could ever compensate for shitty ideology. It all seems like a good excuse to show hypersexual young women and to objectify women, which the camera embraces. Except for the religious girl - called Faith, fuck you Harmony Korine - because, you know there is no nuance between a prude religious girl and hypersexual women. Disgusting." - larmor
#2.
Mother!
30.82% High
"After a third rewatch, this is definitely one of my 100's. I've read about the movie being an allegory of religion etc, but for me it's more fun to enjoy the sequence as a depiction of unmentalised feelings and behavior and a jammed pattern between the two lovers and parents-to-be, alas, in the context of him being famous and self-centered and she admiring him for his fame and wanting him for herself at the same time. Mother! is the most deranged, yet empathetic lovestory ever made." - karlson
24.65% Low
"Remarkably well directed garbage. Truly bad movies are not made by people lacking in skill, but rather by skilled people expertly executing bad ideas." - Glenn Nygard
26.5% High
"Nobody else should bother making 3D films now that Godard has probably taken the format to its apex. At least, that's what I want to say, but I feel like Godard would frown upon that. After all, I think the whole idea behind this film (and most of Godard's career) is that innovation is key, that we must keep progressing - that, in order for the cinema to move forward, we must say goodbye to language and then get to work on creating a brand new one. I'd say that Godard succeeded." - wetwillies
31.05% Low
"Torture. Perhaps it is unfair, but it seemed to this viewer as though the filmmaker possesses a clear understanding that a new cinematic language is required in order to construct a new form of intellectuality and analysis capable of addressing the contemporary age, but that he has no idea whatsoever how to go about achieving this goal. The 3D cinematography is very painful. For me, Godard now has the widest gap between best and worst, achieved across a fifty-year stretch. Enter at own risk." - djross









