The Ten Most Polarizing Films of 2021
It would be an understatement to say that tensions were high in 2021. After all, this was a year which began with a coup attempt at the US Capitol! Covid was still on-going, with multiple variants emerging, and innumerable friendships ruined over whether someone believed in masks or not. People were not getting along, and this polarization extended to the world of cinema as well. We've gathered here the ten most contentious films of this very contentious year -- the ones which nearly an equal amount of people either loved or hated. Where do you stand on the films in this list? Chances are that you feel strongly, one way or the other.
How was this calculated?
For every film with at a certain number of ratings, we calculate the percentage of people who loved it (percentle greater than 75%) and hated it (less than 25%). The "contentiousness" score is the lower of those two percentiles.
Consider the most contentious possible scenario -- an equal number love and hate it, with nobody in between. That would be 50% - 0% - 50%, for a score of "50". Let's say another film has a "love/ambivalence/hate" ratio of "38/30/32". That gets a score of 32: still extremely polarizing!
But a movie that almost everyone hates? Let's say a breakdown of 4/35/61. That's a score of just 4, which means it's not very contentious at all.
#10.
Encanto
19.22% High
"Encanto is a charming, well-made film that tells a thematically-rich, family-focused story. The animation and voice acting is great, giving each character enough of a personality to stand-out but not too much that they become overbearing. The music is enjoyable and catchy, though the songs are a little too faced-paced to be memorable. What the film truly excels at is its themes of inclusion and the stifling nature of rigid expectations. Ultimately, it's an enjoyable film that puts story first." - amazedemon
19.02% Low
"Encanto seeks to answer the age old question of 'What if generational wealth didn't just mean money, land and power, but also came with a sentient house, godlike magical abilities and a sad origin story to justify it all'. If I lived in this town, I might be slightly annoyed that my weather is controlled by the mood of the girl living in the massive mansion at the end of the road, or that their black-sheep brother might seemingly come around at any time and curse away my hair." - Glenn Nygard
27.46% High
"It is now my favorite Romanian film. I'm not taking any questions at this time, but this film so perfectly illustrates the absurdity of living in Romania, the noise, the maddening feelings, the cognitive dissonance, the 'won't somebody think of the children', the inability to reflect on oneself and on patriotism and the really fucked up history. It's bloody genius as far as I'm concerned." - RuruSmasher
19.36% Low
"Meh. I've never been all that thrilled with the blatantly transgressive. Just like porn, it is so obvious." - Icarus
#8.
The Humans
19.4% High
"A peculiarly beautiful inversion of the haunted house genre. Encapsulated in a throwaway line during a dinner party conversation, the film asks what if the humans are the monsters, haunting dark corners? While that conceit can easily become eye-rolling, this film manages to steer clear of being cloying just through its barefaced, vulnerable genuineness. While the script may have have been a stage play, the cinematography consistently elevates it as a movie. The final shot was jaw-dropping." - amerigo
26.72% Low
"I'm realizing I rarely like movies based on plays that are so dialogue driven. I was so bored watching this. I couldn't even view the apartment poorly. All I could see was the potential such a cool space like that had. The wood flooring was great and there's a spiral staircase. What a score! These people droned on and I kept daydreaming of all the ways to fix up the apartment and decorate it." - Adds
19.75% High
"This is definitely what the Justice League was supposed to be. All that and it managed to tease not one or two but three follow-up films. The 4 hours just flew by. Yes there are some problems but I think this is pretty much the best it could've been given the troubled production and the pandemic." - hotsake
26.28% Low
"Crap. After the disasters of Man of Steel and Batman vs Superman there was finally a decent DC movie to get close to the MCU offerings.. there was humor, real people, decent storylines.. The they had to let Snyder back in and ruin Whedon's good work. Had to stop watching after 15 minutes and take a break it was so disappointing. Snyder is someone trying to force his own dark personal issues down the viewers throat while sacrificing the entertainment values from Whedon's version." - sabysims
#6.
Annette
20.44% High
"Wow! For the very first second this totally blew me away. The plot and characters are quite simple, so I can get this doesn't work for everyone, but it's all about the magnificent cinematic experience it created for me. Like the accordion scene in Holy Motors or bridge scence of Les amants du pont-neuf stretched to an entire movie." - LoneWolf2003
27.99% Low
"I have never seen a film that was so proud of its own emptiness. Annette's nihilism is completely unproductive and vain. Annette is laughing at its audience! It's a South Park episode that laughs at you for giving a shit. Carax is deeply sad and depressed. And that could be ok if he wouldn't turn that against his audience who has the audacity to try to make sense of stuff or still hopes for some beauty or joy. I don't think a movie has ever made me angrier, which is almost an achievement!" - Hofschneider
#5.
In the Heights
21.31% High
"I deliberately did not experience the Broadway version, so I'm not comparing to that. Great musical numbers, heartfelt story, well shot & edited. Lin-Manuel Miranda is a genius." - Insti
21.31% Low
"Severely disappointed in this movie. The first I saw from Lin-Emanuel Miranda was Hamilton. I thought it was good and have watched a few of those animated children's movies too and they were enjoyable. This crap movie did not engage me at all. I was bored after less than 15 minutes." - NoiseMaker
#4.
Spencer
21.53% High
"A true masterpiece - not an indictment of the royals, not even a biography or celebration of Diana herself, but a supremely confident, bold, at times mordantly hilarious journey through the mind of a trapped animal; painful and riveting in equal measure. It does help that Stewart does her best work, creating a Diana who is familiar, but also a uniquely sad and haunting creation; knowing what the next years would bring makes the "triumphant" finale unbearably sad and poignant." - glumpy_99
23.53% Low
"Who is this movie for? There's a silent power struggle going on, I guess, but little else. Privileged, sad, crazy woman is privileged, sad, and crazy. Is this even a halfway accurate representation of Diana? The Greenwood score sets the tone early and, quite frankly, takes over the movie. It's a really good score, the movie just doesn't have much else going for it." - matthagen
#3.
West Side Story
22.69% High
"If West Side Story were a human being, I would have married her, because she's just soooooo darn beautiful." - iamianiman
21.94% Low
"I thought I would enjoy it just because I have a soft spot for spectacular dancing/singing scenes, but the songs are terrible and were just really annoying to me (except "America"). The romantic plot might be the WORST EVER screenplay I have witnessed in all movies and series I have seen so far in my entire life. Can't understand why this wasn't improved at least a little bit for the updated version." - Cowman
#2.
Titane
21.99% High
"Wow... What did I just see? I need to watch this again soon to process. Great / Dark / Gruesome. Can anyone say cult classic!?" - radarman01
25.82% Low
"We're supposed to marvel at the protagonist's gruesome senseless violence, and then we're supposed be moved by how she's just compensating for her daddy issues, and then enjoy some pointless body horror cliches. As usual with these trash character studies, Titane overestimates how engaging and empathetic the character really is. It's just too quick to forego any attempt at a moral compass in favor of pop psychology." - Moribunny
#1.
Memoria
33.56% High
"A meditative journey towards the absolute pushed forward by ghostly signals and the technology of nature. Feel like the first 3/4 of this is probably Apichatpong's best and most masterful work. The end is familiar ground for him but the imprint is still undeniable." - deadlilly
22.69% Low
"If it was just a book of screenshots it would probably be decent. But as a movie? Scenes are too long and static. For as good looking at the shots are, they aren't worth staring at for this long. There was no intrigue or engaging characterization. The plot could have been interesting but then you stare at a scene of two people editing sound effects for what feels like half your life. Just lacks the inventiveness that makes Joe's best work so amazing. Edit this down A LOT and then we'll talk." - Obdurate









