>
The Ten Most Polarizing Films of 2023

The Ten Most Polarizing Films of 2023

Every year, there are films which audiences in general seemed to unanimously love, and others which they roundly rejected. But those aren't the films we're interested in for this list. Instead, we're looking at the films which had people split right down the middle -- you might have thought they were terrible or amazing, but you probably weren't ambivalent! Check out the ten most contentious titles of 2023.
How was this calculated?
For every film with at a certain number of ratings, we calculate the percentage of people who loved it (percentle greater than 75%) and hated it (less than 25%). The "contentiousness" score is the lower of those two percentiles.
Consider the most contentious possible scenario -- an equal number love and hate it, with nobody in between. That would be 50% - 0% - 50%, for a score of "50". Let's say another film has a "love/ambivalence/hate" ratio of "38/30/32". That gets a score of 32: still extremely polarizing!
But a movie that almost everyone hates? Let's say a breakdown of 4/35/61. That's a score of just 4, which means it's not very contentious at all.
#10. Talk to Me
21.4% High
"Really loved that it's so messed up with what is real and what is not. It's a horror movie that works well with the creepy and scary, but there's also a lot more to think about here. All the possession scenes were so cool and well-made. The line between reality and horror becomes mixed up at an undetermined point, it's messy and that's why it's so upsetting. Just a very good horror movie that brings something new to the genre." - panzerwolf
16.18% Low
"I don't really understand the hype. Outside of the ending and maybe a couple of decent scenes, there isn't a lot here that stands out. It's not that visually interesting, the story is fine. The characters, whatever. I thought some of it was silly. I mean sure, grabbing a hand to experience ghosts is different I guess? A little corny. This goes for some of the "horror" too. I liked it but it's overrated." - Obdurate
24.16% High
"Strange Darling’s story construction and perspective manipulation is a refreshing and one of the most effective ways to correctly pace a film. Thematically, it doesn’t do much beyond its surface level, but it does leave interesting trails & flares of demoniacal undertones. Fitzgerald/Gallner are absolutely the driving engines of this and this is the best both have ever been. Seemingly, Strange Darling feels artsy in the best ways, without feeling pretentious in a crowded sub-genre of cinema." - Dakota99
16.27% Low
"I made the mistake of watching this while eating breakfast and about had my pumpkin griddlecakes come back up when I got to that cooking scene. Some of those foods should never touch on a plate. My ringtone is literally a joke song about butter and even I think that was too much." - Adds
21.94% High
"So much impeccable work here in terms of character detail, tactile environments, and performances, but my biggest takeaway is that Kelly Reichardt’s films are so soothing. Even this one, with its incredibly prickly protagonist, was just something I relaxed into right away. This has been true of all the films of hers I’ve seen and it makes me very eager to explore the entirety of her back catalogue. (UPDATE: I've seen them all now. They're all great.)" - JLFM
16.88% Low
"Pigeon broken wing recoveries, insufferable artists, Twilight Zone box sets, inconsequential conversations about nothing, cheese platter etiquette, and a broken water heater. The movie has it all! I can't imagine how many takes Reichardt had to do to get just the right amount of banality in every scene. The premier troll job of the year." - matthagen
25.42% High
"The tension is heightened not with cheap jump scares, but with truly terrifying story elements. Filled with harsh, graphic imagery that will haunt you forever, this isn’t a film that relies on the easy scare, but one that is legitimately disturbing." - screenzealot
17.68% Low
"Beautiful use of violence, but the idea was too big, vague, and difficult to produce. It also led to dead ends all over the place. I loved the cinematography, the soundtrack, and the color scheme. I HATED how stupid everything else was. I mean come on... What a waste of a good production crew. The main characters did EVERYTHING anyone with knowledge told them not to. Extremely anticlimactic ending. Truly.... Waste of such great backdrop, money, time, et al." - salman
18.27% High
"I loved this movie. It had a lot of heart with nice subtle humor underneath it. I'm probably Otto." - Ritteh
19.59% Low
"A disgraceful lowpoint in the career of Tom Hanks that will be hard for me to disassociate him from, probably ever. I took 24 hours to let the first wave of emotion and disgust pass, but it hasn't worked. This is in the top 3 worst and most horrible movies i have EVER seen" - sproost
18.44% High
"Another stupendous achievement from Wes, both in his usual ways (perfect framing and production design, phenomenal casting, utterly hilarious and bizarre) and as an exploration of the unknown, grief, and, perhaps most importantly, artifice in storytelling. It’s him confronting and defending his style in a way I never thought he’d do while also being one of the best examples of it to date. What a joy!" - Bown
23.82% Low
"i'm done with this guy. he's a talented writer/director, who then intentionally makes his dialogue and performances so stilted, his production design so precious and twee, until you completely emotionally disconnect from the material. self-parody at this point." - topaz024
#4. Bottoms
24.19% High
"Emma Seligman goes two for two with her hilarious sophomore feature that fully commits to its comedic premise. Rachel Sennot and Ayo Edebiri are as funny as expected, but the rest of the cast was surprisingly good too." - psim
18.81% Low
"Not for me. I thought this was a good concept and remembered similar movies from more than 20 years ago being watchable at least. But I closed this one down after only 20 minutes. Just not interesting." - christoney
#3. Barbie
18.95% High
"Finally, a movie for everyone. A perfect example of Hollywood's ability to fuse art and commerce in a way that, every so often, births a blockbuster where you can feel the culture shifting underneath your multiplex seat. Expertly written and performed, laugh-out-loud funny, gorgeous to look at, etc. etc. but its greatest achievement is provoking a question that I rarely ask anymore as an adult: "Movies can be like THIS?"" - ericambler
27.92% Low
"The (ugly) plasticity of Barbie Land is very well done, however the story is run-of-the-mill and flat, the humour mostly predictable, the characters and settings superficial and contradictory and the dialogues really bad. Of course it's a corporate ad, but the script is a cringe-worthy, facepalm-inducing collection of memes and slogans, a list of declarations and complaints, all presented in the most obvious, unsubtle, patronizing, crude way. For "Barbie" feminism is just another trendy product." - PetrosTser
19.46% High
"Walker directs her young ensemble skillfully and wisely remembers to give her always believable characters breathing room by letting some quiet moments of conversation or reflection punctuate the hard partying that dominates the rest of this top-tier coming of age tale." - KasperL
21.79% Low
"Honestly shocked by the amount of praise this has received, a film whose story can be summarized as lazily as it was written: obnoxious teenage girls go on holiday, one of them is talked into what's eventually a bad sexual experience, then they fly back home. But I'm sure TikTokkers will love it." - frederic_g54
26.05% High
"This is the true becoming of the director for me. I understand it takes a special mood to have the suspension of disbelief. I was immersed through the 3 hours. There have been merely a few films like it in my 5k+ watch list. Joaquin is an actor of a generation. Indie queen Parker is back." - Spunkie
22.08% Low
"Oh my God, what a disappointment coming from Ari Aster. This movie is terribly slow, almost torture. The symbolism it tries to evoke falls flat because the message is so obvious from the beginning: mommy issues made the protagonist a broken man. I will forever despise this movie as I dragged my work colleagues to the cinema to watch it." - gabsvir