The Ten Most Polarizing Films of 2025
Aren't things better when we can all get along? When we all agree on which films we loved, and which we hated? Yeah, come over here, let's have a hug to celebrate that we're always on the same page... wait, what did you say? You think that piece of junk is a "modern classic"? Are you insane? Get away from me, freak, I don't even know who you are anymore!
Actually, we kind of prefer it when movies are divisive. Maybe it's the world we live in, when people can see the same footage of current events, and draw wildly opposite conclusions. Humans are not meant to get along, and a movie that appeals to (or repels) everyone feels like it's missing the zeitgeist. So let's have at it! These are the most polarizing films of 2025, the ones which divided the Criticker community most equally into opposing camps.
How was this calculated?
For every film with at a certain number of ratings, we calculate the percentage of people who loved it (percentle greater than 75%) and hated it (less than 25%). The "contentiousness" score is the lower of those two percentiles.
Consider the most contentious possible scenario -- an equal number love and hate it, with nobody in between. That would be 50% - 0% - 50%, for a score of "50". Let's say another film has a "love/ambivalence/hate" ratio of "38/30/32". That gets a score of 32: still extremely polarizing!
But a movie that almost everyone hates? Let's say a breakdown of 4/35/61. That's a score of just 4, which means it's not very contentious at all.
If you haven't seen them yet, make sure to check out the ten most-hated films of the year at Criticker, and the twenty most-loved!
#10.
Frankenstein
22.49% High
"As beautiful and breathtaking as a film can look and feel. The gothic tone helps set the standard and Jacob Elordi and Oscar Isaac do the rest. Elordi is eloquent in the early stages of the creatures existence as he uses more physical based acting to convey such heavy feelings. Mia Goth also gives Elordi the room to expand what we believe the creature is capable of. Del Toro's film is stunning to behold through all facets of modern film making technology." - kgbelliveau
16.4% Low
"Strikingly similar to Besson's "Dracula" which came out just moments prior, as another grandiose, overfunded, tonally messy, redundant billionth adaptation of a 19th-century gothic novel, and both movies even have Christoph Waltz as himself. Del Toro's, though, is even longer than Besson's, and his overwrought soundtrack is by an Elfman imitator instead of the guy himself. He remains one of the most insufferable filmmakers of our time." - Moribunny
16.67% High
"Love, faith, survival: it’s all about compromise, baby! Living is bartering with your mind, heart, and soul. You can’t just conform; you have to adapt. Reduced me to delighted giggles on multiple occasions, might be Wes’ most visually gorgeous, kiiiiiiinda has the same last shot as Big Night. Wes said we can have a little Jeffrey Wright as a treat, and we should all be GRATEFUL." - JLFM
17.53% Low
"Probably gotta give up on Wes. He's got a very distinct vision, which I can appreciate, and if you take any frame of this movie and use it as a still shot, it's beautiful. Great cast too, like always. Before I saw it, I dug the premise. And there are some jokes that work (the idea that he's always getting assassinated and SABOTAGE) even though they aren't hilarious. But he destroys his own movie. Style over substance is not bad inherently, but his style actively suffocates the substance." - Obdurate
#8.
The Long Walk
16.89% High
"This was an incredibly pretty film. I wasn't expecting that. Excellent shot composition; excellent writing. Thoughtful, and holds important messages, especially in this particular cultural moment when civil liberties seem to be losing their political cachet across parties and countries. This film surpassed my expectations in pretty much every way." - tev
22.75% Low
"Ridiculous premise, ridiculous dialogues, ridiculous distance, ridiculously monotonous, ridiculous ending. Worst King story ever." - guillaume
24.57% High
"Add all the songs to a playlist, give me both light sticks, and let me learn the fan chants." - Adds
17.11% Low
"I found this pretty shallow and painfully generic. Same goes for the music. I did like some of the animation and I'm sure with a bigger budget and/or more time it would have looked even better." - jarobmul
#6.
28 Years Later
17.35% High
"28 Years Later evolves the series without losing its dread-soaked DNA. It’s a film about death—facing it, preparing for it, and what’s left behind. Alfie Williams is the standout, quietly devastating, with strong support from Comer and a scene-stealing Fiennes. The infected are faster, scarier, and more symbolic. Its post-Brexit isolation hits hard, but it’s the final scene—a chilling, provocative nod to Savile—that leaves you reeling. Risky, uncomfortable, and unforgettable." - griggs79
25.92% Low
"Almost 20 years has passed since the first instalment and unfortunately it was not worth the waiting time. Not a whole lot of horror going on and although some of the new additions are interesting they have been exhausted in TWD ad nauseum. The movie plays on an emotional depth but I never cared for any of the characters and found the boy annoying. Add bizarre editing + ending and you have a movie that unfortunately doesn’t warrant the franchise to continue." - SpeedMarque
24.37% High
"It is rare that I leave the theater with a feeling of awe, but I did here. I loved every bit, and the insane runtime flew by for me. It is on par with the first Avatar, and the addition of the ash people was the highlight for me." - Ross
18.07% Low
"An almost unforgivable copy of The Way of Water. Main difference is adding even more new age crap to a world in badly need of better lore. No one cares about Cameron's mythology (or about that Spider-kid) for a reason." - Ofterdingen
#4.
F1: The Movie
19.5% High
"Immersive in IMAX. Glad we saw the final evening showing out here before superman takes over the format tomorrow. Cracking sound design. Pitt was good in his role. There was some chichéd dialogue and a lot of the actual F1 racing was incredibly unrealistic but as it's a movie it's supposed to be. Some aspects felt forced, but for the most part you don't care. You get into the races and it's blissful and engaging stuff for fans. 8.4." - PistolPete
19.17% Low
"It's a cartoon. A dreadful cartoon. Exhausting with its stupidity. Nothing makes sense. It's not cinematic. Every scene is terrible. Go and watch Gran Turismo instead." - Bluemeany20
#3.
Superman
19.78% High
"Really exceeded my expectations. It's a simple enough story, but focuses on the humanity of Superman, and jumps right into things rather than being another origin story. There's a good amount of humor, but it feels fitting and didn't take away the seriousness of the situations, and I liked the whole motif of "maybe that's the real punk rock" being trusting and believing in the goodness of people. Overall, just super entertaining and well-done." - kem1
21.51% Low
"Cringiest thing i have ever seen. Literally try to go out from the movie. Shallow writing, boring fights, simple character design. If you like the man of steel, don't go this. It has marvel movie vibe. We like DC because it is different, serious and darker." - periboku
24.52% High
"filing this away in my optimistic nihilism folder as I quietly forgive mike flanagan for making me cry for three hours (yes it's a two hour movie) and for seemingly hacking into my brain or universe or whatever it is that gives him access to all my idiosyncratic buttons to press" - brell
20.32% Low
"live, laugh, love. dance as if no one's watching, sieze the day! also give me these fucking 90 minutes back." - jlewis
#1.
Eddington
20.83% High
"As much Godard’s La Chinoise as it Altmans McCabe and Mrs Miller. Aster is daring you to hate this. It only “both sides(es)” the hot issues of our time in the sense that everyone in the end bows to only real god in the west. Where truth doesn’t lead you anywhere, or whatever you consider the truth to be anyway. Perfectly haunting final image." - Seethruskin
21.46% Low
"Remember "Midsommar"? Well, this boring piece of crap isn't that. Aster has graduated from not knowing how to finish a story (all his movies unravel one way or another) to not being able to start it. Or tell the middle. Everything about this manages to be somehow even less compelling than "Beau is afraid"." - luord








