>
The Ten Most Polarizing Action Films of All Time

The Ten Most Polarizing Action Films of All Time

Everyone loves a great action movie, right? Well... first, we have to agree on what constitutes "great". And if you take a glance through this list, you'll see that it's not always so easy to agree! According to their ratings at Criticker, these are the ten most polarizing action movies of all time. These are the movies which inspire equal amounts of love and hate, and it's unlikely you feel ambivalent about them. Take a look, and choose a side! Then in the spirit of the genre, grab your nunchuks and challenge anyone who disagrees to an all-out, knock-down brawl in the alley!
How was this calculated?
For every film with at a certain number of ratings, we calculate the percentage of people who loved it (percentle greater than 75%) and hated it (less than 25%). The "contentiousness" score is the lower of those two percentiles.
Consider the most contentious possible scenario -- an equal number love and hate it, with nobody in between. That would be 50% - 0% - 50%, for a score of "50". Let's say another film has a "love/ambivalence/hate" ratio of "38/30/32". That gets a score of 32: still extremely polarizing!
But a movie that almost everyone hates? Let's say a breakdown of 4/35/61. That's a score of just 4, which means it's not very contentious at all.
21.22% High
"Better than the first. The scenes of action are awesome, mixing well with good mood, action and romance." - nandorizzi
21.48% Low
"Even worse than the first. Why these movies get so much critical acclaim is beyond me." - willofgaia
21.48% High
"best feelgood movie that will ever exist. one can argue, that tarantino movies are like sex. if they are (which they are :D), this is the one that most reflects that." - chmul_cr0n
22.55% Low
"A complete waste of a movie. Except for a few great scenes with Russell, it didn't do anything well. 80% of this "slasher" movie was girls driving in cars talking about boys. Tarantino does whatever he wants for no reason and just hopes that fanboys will eat it up. Just awful." - robotjazz
23.01% High
"A marvellous return to Middle-earth. Great adaptation of the source material and it actually adds a lot of depth to a rather straightforward story. Does it have the same scale and gravitas as the Lord of the Rings trilogy? No, but that's not what The Hobbit is about, it's a completely different story set in the same beautiful world." - TheEscapist
21.53% Low
"Peter Jackson manages to get so much wrong - the cinematography is nauseating, most characters are scarcely developed, the peril and the villains feel completely inauthentic, the introduction is overlong and the elements added from the extended Tolkien lore are wholly unnecessary. It can't help but feel like a sloppy outing made purely to cash in on the Lord of the Rings success." - MacSwell
22.03% High
"Don't ask me why I love this movie, I just do. If the perfect score I've given it f**ks up all my TCIs, so be it. If on death row and given the chance to watch one last movie before being executed, yes, I would choose this over the Shawshank Redemption, 2001 A Space Odyssey, and Mad Max Beyond Thunderdome." - Kojiless
22.6% Low
"2 hours of perfect self-satire, but played too straight to do its job very well. When half the audience loves the movie for being great anti-fascists satire, and the other half loves it for its fascists undertones, something probably went wrong somewhere." - Glenn Nygard
#6. Mandy
25.69% High
"I can't even... okay, look. It's like this: If you eat the most goddamn delicious cheeseburger you've ever had in your life, what do you care that they replaced the cheese with LSD?" - DavidBlast
22.32% Low
"What in the ever-loving drug-fueled shock schlock did I just witness." - kem1
29.61% High
"Yes. This is my all-time favourite movie. Amazing acted, amazing plot, amazingly filmed... do you get the idea?" - mrbeck
22.51% Low
"Serves as a litmus test for whose opinions to safely ignore." - schnofel
#4. Versus
23.3% High
"This movie is one of the most badass Japanese movies I've ever seen. The bad guys are hilarious, fun action, a pretty boy kicking ass 2 hours long. I had seriously a fucking great time. Extremely rewatchable too" - begoniabol
23.49% Low
"almost impossible for me to watch, so bad!" - schwabe
23.37% High
"My all time favorite B-movie. It's got everything you ever will need in a shitty action flick: martial arts, cheesy ass poprock songs about ninjas and friendship, ninjas on motorcycles, awkward monologues - ooooof, you just really have to watch this. Just do it. FRIENDS FOR ETERNITY LOYALTY HONESTY" - Pfightmaster
29.29% Low
"The movie equivalent of someone who's never set foot in a kitchen before, trying to make the best fucking sandwich the world has ever seen... Also, he might be high." - FrederikA
#2. Ink
24.86% High
"Acting is just as simple, but powerful. All the magic of the narrative in terms of the simplicity of the production lies in the fact that it avoids ostentation.You question yourself when you follow the cause. Start to question what you live for. Enough to say you're interested in the people you love.Your life is but ambition must watch this movie do.Perhaps under the load without a conscience carry, so you can put an end to this tendency.The location of important words to tell the world what is" - nypielberg
26.92% Low
"Ugly and confusing sci-fi horror botches an intriguing, Nolan-esque dream/reality premise; bears the fingerprints of an amateur production in its garish cinematography, convoluted screenplay and mediocre to poor performances; queasy, scattershot editing makes some sequences very difficult to watch. Some imaginative ideas (and visualisations of the dream people) are ultimately all for naught thanks to the technical deficiencies." - glumpy_99
#1. Avatar
25.3% High
"One of the most satisfying visual displays ever produced. The awe and beauty of this movie is off the charts. I eagerly anticipate a second installment. I liked everything about the Navi, and pretty much disliked everything about the profiteers and military from earth. Many extra points for incredible and amazing imagery. However, Unobtainium? Floating mountains? Dinosaur Army? Really? Subtracting the bad, this is still possibly the best movie ever made." - eCitizen
25.59% Low
"Watching Avatar is like having a stomach-ache from eating too much candy; for nearly three hours long. I found no fun in this film; not in it's predictable characters, nor it's cartoony aesthetic, nor it's tiresome action sequences. I was bored during almost the entirety of this film and I'm astounded by all of the critical praise it's received since it's such a hack attempt. Oh, and the 3-D didn't help it either." - Neonman