The Ten Most Polarizing Animated Films of All Time
There are animated classics that everyone agrees on. Parents and children both love Pixar's Up unconditionally, right? And who doesn't agree that The Iron Giant is an all-time classic? Well, these aren't the types of animated films we're looking at today. No, we want the ones that have as many detractors as they have fans. The ones which make some people wild with delight, and others frothing with rage. We've crunched the numbers, and these are the ten most polarizing animated films of all time.
How was this calculated?
For every film with at a certain number of ratings, we calculate the percentage of people who loved it (percentle greater than 75%) and hated it (less than 25%). The "contentiousness" score is the lower of those two percentiles.
Consider the most contentious possible scenario -- an equal number love and hate it, with nobody in between. That would be 50% - 0% - 50%, for a score of "50". Let's say another film has a "love/ambivalence/hate" ratio of "38/30/32". That gets a score of 32: still extremely polarizing!
But a movie that almost everyone hates? Let's say a breakdown of 4/35/61. That's a score of just 4, which means it's not very contentious at all.
#10.
Encanto (2021)
19.48% High
"Encanto is a charming, well-made film that tells a thematically-rich, family-focused story. The animation and voice acting is great, giving each character enough of a personality to stand-out but not too much that they become overbearing. The music is enjoyable and catchy, though the songs are a little too faced-paced to be memorable. What the film truly excels at is its themes of inclusion and the stifling nature of rigid expectations. Ultimately, it's an enjoyable film that puts story first." - amazedemon
18.08% Low
"mish-mash of random scenes OTT visually. Ritalin powered animation, within 10 minutes we have about 184 characters jostled in, non of them given any character, all are just defined by some 'issue'. No actual storytelling on display, everything is just thrown in as and when needed. Children won't understand or be interested in much of it, it's clearly cynically aimed at adults - student demo." - gogolit
#9.
Ice Age (2002)
18.41% High
"As opposed to many animated films, whose characters seem to be overcharged on caffiene, Ice Age's Manny (a moody mammoth) has a relaxed and easy-going manner that nicely complents the hyperactive Sid (a simple-minded sloth) and the crusty Diego (a coniving smilodon). Even Diego finds himself won over by by Manny's warm heart and selfless loyalty to his friends, no matter how shiftless and annoying they might be." - Kadrian
18.42% Low (2022)
"Lacking any subversive wit that usually draws more mature audiences to this kind of film, it's just a series of obvious jokes (extinction and evolution one-liners) and cliche plot progression (what are three MEN gonna do with a baby?!)." - Nathan S
#8.
Turning Red
18.66% High
"Every second of Turning Red is an enjoyable delight. This was my friends and I in 2002, so there's plenty of relatable nostalgia for me personally. Yet this is a fresh coming of age story both kids and adults should find easy to watch and love." - Adds
18.58% Low
"Life lesson, kids : if you can't get what you want, which is shallow consumption of mainstream idols, you can always go behind your parents' back and sell your body." - martryn
#7. (1988)
The Land Before Time
18.89% High
"Childhood favorite that's heartfelt enough to likely last me a lifetime. Gorgeous, inventive animation, environments, and action; by turns whimsical and tragic, with a powerful and well-formed story; fantastic characters and a beautiful soundtrack (no wonder, it was originally meant to have no dialog)." - machchunk
19.06% Low
"Ugh. Cute kid dinosaurs in a cute animated adventure. The only good part is when their parents die." - TheDenizen
#6.
Mad God (2022)
28% High
"I watched this dead sober, and that might have been a mistake. If I had been intoxicated under some kind of substance, I might have been able to write off parts of the movie as a hallucination or false memory. It's godly animation of the most ungodly things imaginable. Disgusting, horrifying... More than any other movie, this made me feel like I was staring into hell. I had nightmares for a straight two weeks after seeing it." - Trooth
18.93% Low
"No coherent story or even themes (life and death?) to unify what feels like a series of disjointed vignettes." - burner010101
#5.
Lilo & Stitch (2002)
19.54% High
"Fresh, quirky, hilarious and full of unique characters and plot elements that create a highly entertaining, heart-felt story. It appeals to adults as well as children. One of Disney's most original and fun!" - Shephard
18.98% Low
"It's like an animated version of Monkey Trouble. I hate this film, and although I try to keep my reviews less angry, this will be an exception. The movie is so painfully stupid. Any bit of cuteness or attachment is ruined, because the character Stitch is so completely obnoxious, and he never improves, so I wonder why the film even happens. The little girl should realize that her new monster dog is a rotten turd of a being and deserves no love, just like the rest of the film! Total crap!" - BattleToad
#4.
The Congress (2013)
25.32% High
"A wonderful mind-expending daring drug movie (uhh, my favorite!), certainly with a lot of edge to it. You have here some strong culture critisism and that haunting feeling of an incurably long bad trip." - SheWas
19.53% Low
"Distinctly less than the sum of its many parts. Film has a lot of things it wants to say and do but it would have been better off just picking one of them, instead of throwing them all into a blender and hoping for the best. There's some artful family drama stuff in the beginning that soon gets swept away amongst trite dialogue and queasy scattergun satire. The Filmmaker this ain't. The animation segment is completely jarring, and a mess narratively. Overall it's juvenilia, and pretty disengenuous." - Harmonica
#3.
The Transformers: The Movie (1986)
25.56% High
"This movie blew my mind away when I saw it in the theatre. First, I was five years old. Second, characters were dying left and right and saying "shit" and "dammit." Great animation (although I'm not an expert), and bitchin' soundtrack. Awesome." - BBBD
20.02% Low
"Tiring, noisy and confusing cartoon does make you wonder if the Michael Bay films were really *that* bad! - outside of the quagmire, perhaps most notable for its eclectic voice cast and as a swan-song for Welles, whose voice can be heard buried somewhere under all those electronics! Looks (and sounds) like an extended TV episode (along with commercial fadeouts!) and about as enjoyable for a 30 something not raised on the TV show." - Glumpy_99
22.03% High
"Shinkai's best movie to date is this highly complex/rich movie which is among the most visually impressive movies ever made, animated or not. This movie is worth watching just for the visuals." - Guaporense
20.68% Low
"I am following Shinkai's career right from the start, and while his stories always lacked complexity, he had his own way to provoke happy-sad emotion. With each movie he was getting better, so my expectations for this one were high. What a great disappointment it was to find that Hoshi o ou kodomo is just a bad imitation of Miyazaki's Laputa. Story lacks coherence, characters are shallow - I was bored out of my mind watching this. Animation is good, but not his best." - chemical404
#1.
Team America: World Police (2004)
21.08% High
"Matt and Trey have a unique ability to present clever satire in the most completely immature way possible. More laughs than almost any other movie I've seen. The melancholy version of "America, Fuck Yeah" kills me." - mattorama12
23.12% Low
"I did not expect such garbage to come from the minds of two comedic geniouses. Trey Parker and Matt Stone created South Park. Now, with this release, they have also created manure. Absolutely disgustingly horrible. I'm apaulled to have spent $4 to rent this crap." - AsILayDying









