The Ten Most Polarizing TV Shows of the 2000s
Ahh... the 2000s! Remember them? The first decade of the 21st century was a golden age for television — a period when the medium began to take itself seriously as an art form. Prestige dramas pushed storytelling to new heights, reality TV exploded onto our screens and changed the culture forever, and the rise of cable gave creators the freedom to go places broadcast networks never would.
And what a lineup they gave us. Iconic shows like The Wire (2002), Lost (2004), The Office (2005), 30 Rock (2006), and Breaking Bad (2008) defined what TV could be — and many of them hold up to this day. But not every show won universal praise. Television has always had the power to divide: what feels like a guilty pleasure to one viewer is pure torture to another, and what one person calls groundbreaking, another calls overrated. We've run the numbers at Criticker, and found the ten most polarizing TV shows of the 2000s. Do you remember any of these? Or maybe you're still watching them?
How was this calculated?
For every title with at a certain number of ratings, we calculate the percentage of people who loved it (percentle greater than 75%) and hated it (less than 25%). The "contentiousness" score is the lower of those two percentiles.
Consider the most contentious possible scenario -- an equal number love and hate it, with nobody in between. That would be 50% - 0% - 50%, for a score of "50". Let's say another title has a "love/ambivalence/hate" ratio of "38/30/32". That gets a score of 32: still extremely polarizing!
But a show that almost everyone hates? Let's say a breakdown of 4/35/61. That's a score of just 4, which means it's not very contentious at all.
#10.
True Blood
20.65% High
"The series started off strong, and stayed that way for quite some time. Good actors, solid drama and romance, but unfortunately the last couple seasons lose focus and it ends in an unsatisfying way" - morphinapg
21.84% Low
"I really thought this show had potential based on the premise and the fact that it was on HBO. It wasn't as terrible as it probably could have been, but its greatest accomplishment was simply being slightly better than its contemporary vampire shows and movies." - mattorama12
21.54% High
"This show is so silly, but takes itself so seriously that I love it. This is one of my favorite shows ever. The fact that almost every single thing in the show is show involves someone losing their soul is totally awesome. I love introducing this show to friends and looking at their reactions when some BS happens that makes Yugi win a duel." - TheSheriff
25.38% Low
""I'm going to attack the moon! Kuribo! Kunai with Chain!" The series is silly but the characters have a certain unintended charm." - Scuffed
21.56% High
"I looooved this show so much. Though I think it ended at the right time I could've watched it for many more years. Desperate Housewives got that suspense/humor combination all figured out. This is definitely one of a kind show." - CocoRamirez
29.36% Low
"Boring." - samajully
22.12% High
"I watch it every Friday. I don't agree with everything Bill or his guests say, but that's exactly the point." - MontyCircus
25.96% Low
"only watched one episode. didn't agree with half the stuff he said but that's ok, the real problem is that it didn't cause a single laugh." - babaracus
#5.
Little Britain
22.5% High
"adore this show, and its really accurate" - CaptainGoat
33.75% Low
"Talk about running things into the fucking ground." - overrated
#4.
The O.C.
24.36% High
"Great guilty pleasure teen soap. Unlike 99% of other teen soaps, it actually ends on a high note, as the fourth and final season is the best of all four and the series finale is great. Seth Cohen may be Josh Schwartz's best character." - Ytadel
23.64% Low
"Somehow was sucked into watching two seasons of this with friends, eventually had to get up off the couch against my will." - overrated
#3.
One Tree Hill
24.24% High
"As I repeatedly tell my friends: this show changed my life and the ways I look at certain things. It also gave me really high expectations of live, love and relationships. The thing about this show is that you will only appreciate it and see the beauty in it when you watch it from season 1 to 9. Only then you'll realize that the soundtrack is one of the main characters or that Brooke Davis is one of the best TV characters ever written or that greatness actually lies in the detail." - CocoRamirez
27.27% Low
"Being married for ten years I probably had to sit through half of this series. It seemed like they were surprised it kept getting renewed as they kind of ran out of shit to do and people to fuck and lie to." - hellboy76
#2.
Survivor
34.72% High
"The single greatest tv reality competition show ever created" - AlexBrisson
24.54% Low
"I BLAME YOU FOR ALL REALITY TV SURVIVOR" - Ytadel
36.41% High
"This is one of my favorite shows. I watched during the early season's and then picked back up during the pandemic. It's such a fun celebration of Queer culture and artistry." - Sneezy0984
25.13% Low
"Love the costumes, love the LGBT spotlight, but it’s the snarky, caustic, catty attitude is just not my thing. Still reeks of the usual reality TV small-minded pettiness." - crowey









