The Ten Most Polarizing TV Shows of the 2010s
In the 2010s, it seems people were fighting about everything... so why should TV be any different? This contentious decade saw the release of a lot of shows which got people riled up. I don't know, it feels like people should be able to agree on what constitutes "quality" television programming, but as you're about to see, that is not the case. These ten series from the 2010s had people bitterly divided. Which side did you fall on?
How was this calculated?
For every title with at a certain number of ratings, we calculate the percentage of people who loved it (percentle greater than 75%) and hated it (less than 25%). The "contentiousness" score is the lower of those two percentiles.
Consider the most contentious possible scenario -- an equal number love and hate it, with nobody in between. That would be 50% - 0% - 50%, for a score of "50". Let's say another title has a "love/ambivalence/hate" ratio of "38/30/32". That gets a score of 32: still extremely polarizing!
But a show that almost everyone hates? Let's say a breakdown of 4/35/61. That's a score of just 4, which means it's not very contentious at all.
#10.
The Blacklist
21.15% High
"This show has severe weaknesses which would impact my rating if I didn't enjoy the show hours on hours on end" - egloo
25.7% Low
"It started out as enjoyable, but season after season, the same old story just dragged on and on. It's tiresome, cliche, and redundant. Should have ended many seasons ago." - SammyRizz
#9.
Girls
26.53% High
"my relationship to this is complicated, but it's still very important to me" - cyborg
21.17% Low
"Honestly, if I'd watched this dull, unfunny, plotless show about spoiled, hateworthy young New Yorkers in a vacuum, I might have just found it regular-bad. But I lived through the 2012 Girls Storm, when every single TV site on the internet published no less 100 articles about how you are misogynistic subhuman trash if you don't think this show is the greatest masterpiece since The Godfather, so I viciously despite it. Ironically (given the show's title), Adam Driver is the sole bright spot." - Ytadel
21.23% High
"The filler episodes felt like they slowed down the plot to almost a crawl and for a series taking on instituionalized racism as the main subject that definitely hurt. It was still very engaging and the cultural subject matter definitely elevated it above most shows in the intelligence category. Hoping for a season 2 and hoping for more overall progression within that season. There is a lot of ground they can cover and most of it was already touched upon." - kgbelliveau
27.4% Low
"It's not that Dear White People doesn't hit - it just misses far more often." - ATiM2
#7.
Jane the Virgin
26.67% High
"Yeah. Perfect score. This show has my heart and soul. It has no right to work as well as it does, and yet, the whole blending of genres plus absolutely staying true to the emotional honesty of the characters, it's one of the best thing out there. Straight out of a telenovela, right? Also a very authentic depiction of trying to be a writer these days. And beyond the many nuanced and amazing female characters, the show also has super refreshing views on masculinity. Gina is a TREASURE." - RuruSmasher
21.25% Low
"I wanted so much to like this, but the grating self-awareness turned me off. Also how hard is it for shows about Latinx people be run by Latinx creators, like the great Vida?" - redboots
21.45% High
"Great show, solid acting, memorable characters each season, and a strong story that benefits from its isolated season arcs, which means that someone can choose any season they want to start out with. the pacing is good and keeps you hooked and satisfied." - Squinty
22.35% Low
"Good acting and writing (though inconsistent) marred by a narrative empty of any meaning or any overarching goal besides some sort of fetish for appearing weird and depressing. Ends up being all over the place and doesn't know when or where to stop. Superficial at best, irritating at worst." - mattornot
#5.
Transparent
34.86% High
"The Pfeffermans are probably the most neurotic, self-involved family on "TV" and honestly this show is very hard to watch at points because of how convincingly their roles are performed. However, their chaotic and unconventional family lends itself to a myriad of tender, humorous, and all-too-human moments of breathtaking imperfection. There isn't really a show quite like this anywhere else and its voice is of the now and important. It's really a "warts and all" experience, that's for sure." - bakcheia
21.71% Low
"Incredible acting, but not funny nor dramatic, just pretentious and boring. Full of sex, religion, lies, secrets and failures, but I could not care for any of it. A great way to ruin an excellent soundtrack." - bowfinger
#4.
The Witcher
21.87% High
"It fixes fun fantasy monster hunting with a dark storyline. I love it." - Jessjess125
22.54% Low
"A generic fantasy series which fails at what made the original story successful, and also follows the trend of mixing in the views of modern day Hollywood instead of adapting the actual story." - sfgse83rf3
#3.
The Walking Dead
22.34% High
"I love this show. When it first aired, I was incredibly happy that there finally was a TV shows with my beloved zombies. Even though there are a few really slow episodes, I still love it. Character development and all aside, the creators get seriously creative with the zombie kills :)" - sophie
25.07% Low
"Starts out ok-ish, gets terrible really fast and then slides of into realms of pure trash when they realized no matter how hard they fuck up their uncritical viewership doesnt mind." - Henno
#2.
Big Mouth
25.9% High
"In the push to differentiate, it seems like animation just gets uglier and uglier. And there are definitely some gross-out type jokes that just feel try-hard and don't work. But once you get past that, there's a seriously hilarious show that has a creative angle on depicting puberty. The show just keeps getting better, too." - mattorama12
22.67% Low
"Ugly animation and a script that is frequently gross and cringeworthy, but absolutely never funny, nor clever nor original." - Moribunny
#1.
Queer Eye
23.5% High
"I genuinely like this show because it has a heart and the Fab Five seem to genuinely want to help people make a difference in their lives" - Ms. C
31.69% Low
"In early seasons, it has a heartfelt, addictive quality that passes on some important messages, but it's also just straight-up capitalist propaganda a lot of the time. Later seasons (around season 5 or 6?) have a marked drop in quality, with product placement becoming egregious and the whole production feeling tense and rushed." - emtilt









