Definitely a mixed bag of "welcome back!" and "this again?". My points were lower if gilbert didn't acknowledge the futility of recreating the past in a sweet little post-completion message. The hate for the art-style is unwarranted, the puzzles on the other hand are rarely creative or in need of the series' signature outside the box-thinking. Thus, the new hint system is pretty obsolete, although i get the sad reality behind implementing it for all the challenged attention spans out there.

Weird graphical choice, sometimes it's efficient (LeChuck's boat), but most of the time it looks cheap. Anyway, it recaptures Monkey Island 1&2 spirit at its best, and it was fun and addictive.