Dragon Age: Origins

geniasis
Review by
10 Nov 2026
Good
73rd percentile
89
This review contains spoilers
A World Cut in Two: Dragon Age: Origins and the Colonial Imagination

Behind the wall

"The colonial world is a world cut in two," Frantz Fanon wrote at the start of The Wretched of the Earth, and he meant it almost as a map. On one side sits the settler's town: "strongly built, all made of stone and steel," brightly lit, its streets clean. On the other sits the native quarter, "a world without spaciousness," where "men live there on top of each other." Between them runs a line drawn by barracks and police stations.

Dragon Age: Origins is one of the very few blockbuster fantasies that understands this as geography before it understands it as plot. Pick the City Elf origin and your story opens behind a wall in Denerim, in the Alienage: a crowded, ramshackle quarter built around a single sacred tree. City guards stand at the gate. The humans who come through it arrive as landlords, sightseers or predators. Fanon's sentence has become level design.

The game's title is more honest than it looks. BioWare built six possible openings: human noble, city elf, Dalish elf, dwarf noble, dwarf commoner, circle mage. Each one starts you at a different point along that dividing line, and each is a short, cruel lesson in what Fanon called being "overdetermined from without." Before you have made a single meaningful choice, the world has already decided what your ears, your caste or your magic make you.

That is the game's great achievement, and in 2009 it was a startling one. Seventeen years on, it is still the richest thing BioWare has made. But the main plot sits awkwardly on top of all this careful social knowledge. The Blight, a tide of monstrous darkspawn, gives Ferelden exactly what a colonial order always wants: an enemy so absolute that every other conflict can be put on hold. Origins is the story of the colonized being drafted to save the world that colonized them. The game knows this better than it is able to say.

The knife and the conscription

The City Elf origin is built around a wedding that never happens. Vaughan Kendells, the arl's son, crashes it with his friends and carries off the bride and her cousin Shianni for an evening of "sport." You go after them, through his estate, sword in hand. When you reach him you can take his bribe, or you can kill him.

Fanon's most notorious claim is that, "at the level of individuals, violence is a cleansing force. It frees the native from his inferiority complex and from his despair and inaction." Few games of its era were willing to give the player that catharsis so plainly, and the sequence still lands. It is worth naming its limit, too. The game uses the sexual violation of elven women as the spark for the hero's awakening, a convention it borrows rather than questions, though Shianni's fury afterwards gives the injury a voice of its own.

Then comes the turn that defines the whole game. The guards arrive and someone must hang. Duncan, commander of the Grey Wardens, invokes the Right of Conscription and takes you away. The act of resistance is captured by an institution the moment it happens and pointed outward, at the Blight.

For Fanon, the violence of the colonized is supposed to spread. It is meant to be collective, to remake a people from the inside. Here it is made private and then exported. The Alienage stays exactly as it was; the elf who struck back is shipped off to fight a war on everyone's behalf. Every origin repeats the pattern. The dwarf is pulled out of Dust Town, the mage out of the tower, the Dalish hunter away from the clan. Each is lifted out of the place of their particular oppression and enlisted in a universal cause.

The Wardens insist they are "above politics," and Marx would recognize the move at once. In The German Ideology he argues that each ruling order must "represent its interest as the common interest of all the members of society" and "give its ideas the form of universality." The Blight is universality in its purest form. The cleverness, and the danger, is that the threat is real. The darkspawn really will eat everyone. Ideology works best when it is not a lie but a true emergency that conveniently postpones every other question.

The darkspawn themselves are the colonizer's fantasy made flesh. Fanon describes how colonial discourse paints the native as "insensible to ethics," as "the absolute evil." The darkspawn have no culture, almost no speech and no inner life. Killing them costs nothing. The game needs them that way, so that hundreds of fights won't trouble the conscience its opening chapters have just woken up.

Yet the writers cannot quite leave it there. Becoming a Warden means drinking darkspawn blood in the Joining, so the hero carries the enemy's taint. Deep in the dwarven roads you learn that broodmothers, the creatures that breed the horde, are made from captured women. The most dehumanized thing in Ferelden turns out to be made out of people. The game builds a perfect Manichean enemy and then quietly undercuts it.

The tower and the phylactery

If the Alienage is Fanon's divided city, Kinloch Hold is Foucault's institution. The Circle of Magi sits in a tower on an island in Lake Calenhad. Children who show magical talent are taken there and raised under the watch of the templars. To become full mages they must pass the Harrowing, a solo ordeal against a demon in the dream-world of the Fade; those who fail are cut down on the spot. A vial of each mage's blood, the phylactery, is kept so that runaways can be tracked anywhere in the world.

This is not a dungeon. It is a machine for producing a certain kind of person. Foucault's line from Discipline and Punish, "the soul is the prison of the body," fits the Circle almost too well, because the mages are taught to police themselves long before a templar raises a sword. The phylactery turns the mage's own body into the watchtower. Wherever you run, your blood is already reporting on you.

The Rite of Tranquility is the system's masterpiece. It cuts a mage off from the Fade and, with it, from strong feeling and dreams. The Tranquil are calm, obedient and useful; they craft enchantments and run the tower's stores. Foucault said discipline increases the body's forces "in economic terms of utility" while it diminishes them "in political terms of obedience." Owain, standing placidly at his stockroom counter, is that sentence in a robe.

Here Fanon and Foucault meet on surprising ground. Fanon was a working psychiatrist, and at the Blida-Joinville hospital in Algeria he saw how the colonial situation produced the very disorders the asylum then claimed to treat. When he resigned in 1956 he wrote that the Algerian, "permanently an alien in his own country, lives in a state of absolute depersonalization." The Circle works the same way. Jowan's turn to blood magic is born of terror that he will be made Tranquil; the institution creates the danger it exists to contain.

This is where the game hedges. In the Broken Circle quest the tower has fallen to Uldred's uprising, and the uprising is literally demonic. Rebel mages have become abominations. The Chantry even teaches that the darkspawn first came into the world through the pride of ancient mages. Fantasy has one power that realist fiction lacks: it can make the oppressor's fears true. Colonial discourse insists the native is dangerous by nature. Origins builds a cosmology where mages really are doorways for demons.

The game's sympathy for its mages is real. Wynne, Jowan and the apprentices you can save are drawn with care, and later games in the series would pull this thread all the way to open revolt. But in this first installment the plot sides, finally, with the templars' fear. It is the one place where the game seems to agree with the people holding the keys.

Brands, Memories and the Anvil

Orzammar, the dwarven city under the mountains, layers two kinds of power on top of each other. The older kind writes directly on the body. The casteless of Dust Town carry a brand on their faces, a mark that bars them from honest work and tells every noble in the Diamond Quarter what they are. The newer kind works through the archive. The Shaperate keeps the Memories, the record of every dwarf who matters, and the casteless are simply not in it.

Foucault described the archive as "the law of what can be said," the system that decides which lives can appear in history at all. Orzammar makes that literal. When a dwarf commoner becomes a Warden, they are entered into the Memories for the first time. Recognition arrives as a gift from the very institution that erased them.

The Dust Town origin is where Marx and Fanon openly disagree, and the game picks a side. The casteless survive through the Carta, a criminal syndicate. Your sister Rica works as a "noble hunter," hoping to bear a noble's son and lift the family by birth. Marx had nothing but contempt for this class. In The Eighteenth Brumaire he called the lumpenproletariat the "scum, offal, refuse of all classes," a pool of hired muscle for reaction. Fanon turned that on its head: in the colonies, he argued, the lumpenproletariat "constitutes one of the most spontaneous and the most radically revolutionary forces of a colonized people."

Origins sides with Marx. The Carta are just criminals, serving whichever patron pays. Orzammar's politics are entirely a contest between nobles, Bhelen against Harrowmont. Tellingly, the candidate most likely to open doors for the casteless is Bhelen, a fratricidal schemer who pursues reform with an iron fist. It is the logic Marx applied to British rule in India: a brutal modernizer dissolves caste because caste gets in the way of trade. Fanon would refuse that bargain. Progress delivered by a tyrant, for the tyrant's reasons, does not make a people free.

The Anvil of the Void is the most quietly radical sequence in the game. Long ago the smith Caridin found a way to forge golems, tireless war machines, out of living dwarves. The first were volunteers; later, the powerful sent those they could spare. Paragon Branka has sacrificed her whole house to rediscover the method. Your companion Shale, a sardonic golem who despises pigeons, turns out to have been a dwarf woman once.

Marx has a sentence for this. "Capital is dead labour, that, vampire-like, only lives by sucking living labour." The Anvil is that conversion as a piece of machinery: a living worker turned into a permanent instrument, cheap to keep and impossible to tire. The game frames your choice, to destroy the Anvil or keep it for the war, as a hard question about winning. Marx would frame it as the question every economy answers daily, and Fanon would note whose bodies end up in the forge.

Fragments of Arlathan

The Dalish elves have refused the Alienage. They wander the forests in their landships, their faces marked with vallaslin, the blood-writing that honors gods no one alive has seen. Their Keepers piece together the lore of a lost elven empire from scraps, songs and ruins. They are a people living inside the archive of their own loss.

Fanon wrote about this position with real tenderness and real impatience. In "On National Culture" he describes the colonized intellectual who turns to the precolonial past and finds only "a stock of particularisms," who wants to reach the people "but instead only catches hold of their outer garments." A national culture, he insists, "is not a folklore." It lives in the present struggle, not in the careful reconstruction of what was taken.

The game is kind to the Dalish without flattering them. Their grief is beautiful and their pride is earned. But they also sneer at city elves as "flat-ears," and that contempt is exactly the kind of division a colonial order profits from. Two halves of one dispossessed people are kept busy despising each other.

The Nature of the Beast quest pushes this further. Centuries ago, humans attacked Keeper Zathrian's clan; his son was killed and his daughter assaulted, and she later took her own life. Zathrian answered with a curse that turned the attackers and their descendants into werewolves. He has kept himself alive for centuries so the curse will not die with him.

Zathrian is Fanon's nightmare: violence that does not open onto a new humanity but preserves the wound forever. For Fanon, the violence of the colonized was meant to end something, to clear the ground. Zathrian's has become a culture of its own. The quest's best ending asks him to lift the curse, and lifting it costs him his life. That is a sharp idea, and the game gets it right. When an identity is built entirely from an injury, giving up the injury feels like dying.

Fanon closed Black Skin, White Masks with a refusal that reads like a rebuke to Zathrian: "I am not a prisoner of history." The Dalish can still choose that. Zathrian chooses it only at the cost of everything he had become.

The hero of River Dane

It is easy to forget that Ferelden is a postcolonial nation. A generation before the game begins, King Maric and his commoner-born general Loghain Mac Tir drove out the Orlesian occupiers. Loghain is the hero of that liberation. At Ostagar, in the game's first great betrayal, he withdraws his troops and leaves Maric's son, King Cailan, to die. He then takes power as regent and brands the Wardens as traitors.

Fanon's chapter "The Pitfalls of National Consciousness" reads like a briefing on Loghain. Fanon warned that the leaders of a liberation often inherit the colonial machinery and turn it on their own people. National feeling hardens into paranoia; the hero of independence becomes the guardian of order. Loghain sees the Orlesian hand everywhere, including behind the Wardens. Every crime he commits, he commits in the name of never being occupied again.

The Unrest in the Alienage quest reveals how that order is paid for. Denerim's Alienage has been sealed under a plague quarantine. Tevinter "healers" have set up a hospice, and the sick elves who go inside are never seen again. In fact they are being sold as slaves, under a writ that bears Loghain's signature.

Foucault opens his famous chapter on panopticism with the plague town of the seventeenth century: every house shut, every street watched, every person fixed in place. For him it was "the utopia of the perfectly governed city." The game turns that utopia into a cover story. The quarantine is how the state hides an act of extraction. Marx supplies the last word on what is being extracted. The history of primitive accumulation, he wrote, "is written in the annals of mankind in letters of blood and fire." Ferelden's war chest is literally made of elven bodies.

This is the most damning thing the game says, and it says it clearly. The nation's liberation rests on the backs of its internal colonized. But look at where the game spends its moral seriousness afterward. The Landsmeet, the duel, the option to spare Loghain and recruit him into the Wardens: all of that complexity goes to the tragic patriot. The elves he sold appear mostly as evidence, documents waved before a council of nobles.

Fanon would notice who gets an inner life. Loghain can be redeemed partly because the people he sold do not vote at the Landsmeet. That is the game's blind spot, though it is also, to its credit, something the game lets you see if you look.

A boon from the throne

The game ends with the Archdemon dead on a rooftop in Denerim and a run of epilogue slides. A new monarch takes the throne and may grant the hero a boon. Reforms arrive, if they arrive, as favors from the crown.

In Black Skin, White Masks, Fanon has a chapter on Hegel's master and slave. Hegel's slave wins recognition through struggle. Fanon argues that the colonized were denied even that: freedom was handed down without a fight, so no real recognition ever took place. "The upheaval reached the Negro from without. The black man was acted upon." Liberation that is given rather than taken leaves the old hierarchy in place, now wearing a kinder face.

Origins re-enacts this at the level of its design. Your Warden, even an elf from the Alienage, becomes the hand through which change is dispensed. The interface itself is what Foucault called government: the management of whole populations. You decide which peoples march, who rules Orzammar, whether the mages are purged and whose curse is lifted. The knife you raised in the Alienage has, by the final act, turned into patronage.

And still, play the City Elf and the ending carries a real charge. The elf whom the arl's guards would have hanged is the one who kills the Archdemon and stands before the throne. That is not nothing. It is also the fantasy of the heroic exception, the one who proves himself worthy and is admitted, a figure Fanon knew well and distrusted deeply. One elf is honored; the wall around the Alienage still stands.

None of this makes Origins less of an achievement. If anything it explains why the game still matters. Its origins structure, which lets you live the world from different rungs before you are asked to save it, is a genuine formal invention that few RPGs since have matched. Its writing is dense, funny and morally alert. Its companions argue with you and with each other: Morrigan sneering at Chantry pieties, Sten judging the south's chaos from outside, Alistair torn between duty and the throne he never wanted. Ferelden feels like a real society with real fault lines, because it was built by people who had thought hard about where those lines fall.

Fanon ended The Wretched of the Earth by calling on readers to "work out new concepts, and try to set afoot a new man." Dragon Age: Origins cannot do that. No fantasy built on the bones of a medieval kingdom really can. But it maps the walls of its world so precisely that you can see exactly where the new concepts would have to begin. It knows where the wall is. It just can't imagine the city without it.
Mini Review: Dragon Age: Origins opens behind walls: an elven ghetto, a mage tower, a caste-branded slum. Each is a colonial world cut in two, and the game maps them with rare precision. Its limit is the Blight, an enemy so purely evil that every injustice can wait while the oppressed are drafted to save their oppressors. Foucault sees the tower’s discipline; Marx sees the call to unity as ideology. The game knows where the wall is. It can’t imagine the city without it.
Watch the Trailer