Grand Theft Auto

geniasis
Review by
03 Dec 2023
Not That Hot
34th percentile
76
This review contains spoilers
The Spectacle Learns to Drive

The God's-Eye City

The first thing you notice about the original Grand Theft Auto is that you never see the city the way a person would. You hover above it. Liberty City, San Andreas and Vice City are laid out beneath you like a transit map that someone has filled with traffic, pedestrians and police. When you speed up, the camera pulls back, so the faster you go the more of the grid you take in. Before the franchise put you behind a shoulder or inside a cockpit, it gave you the view of a planner, a traffic controller, a landlord looking over his property. Everything about this 1997 game from DMA Design follows from that bird's-eye view.

Guy Debord and the Situationists spent much of the 1950s and 60s arguing that the modern city was a machine for keeping people on rails: home to work to shop and back home, with every block designed to move bodies and goods efficiently. Their answer was the dérive, the aimless drift. You walk through the city with no purpose, follow its moods instead of its signs, and so find the cracks where everyday life might escape the routes laid down for it. Read that way, the original Grand Theft Auto is a strange object. It is a drifting machine, perhaps the first commercial software built around wandering a city with nowhere you have to be. It also proves Debord's darkest point. Society's ability to absorb the gestures meant to resist it has no limit. The drift became a product, and the product sold millions.

That is my argument. Grand Theft Auto is not a satire of the society of the spectacle, though it sometimes looks like one. It is the spectacle learning to give you the steering wheel. The game hands the player the most radical things the Situationists imagined doing to a city: drifting, derailing, disrupting traffic, turning ordinary order into play. Then it scores them. It is a fascinating and frequently thrilling game, and it is also a revealing one, because it is so crude. The machinery that later entries would render seamless is still visible here.

Everything Converts

The score is the key to the game. To clear a level in Grand Theft Auto you don't defeat a boss or reach a destination. You hit a points target. Missions pay points, delivered as orders from ringing payphones. So does wrecking a car, gunning down a pedestrian, or dragging a cop out of his cruiser. Running over a line of chanting devotees earns the infamous "Gouranga!" bonus. The Kill Frenzy power-ups set a timer and pay you to fill the screen with bodies. Finishing jobs raises your multiplier, so every later act of destruction is worth more. Whatever you do, it ends up as a number in the corner of the screen.

This is about as pure a dramatization of the commodity form as a game has managed. Debord's central claim is that the spectacle is not just a collection of images. It is a social relation between people, mediated by images, in which everything lived recedes into representation. Beneath that sits Marx's older point that exchange value makes unlike things equivalent: a coat and twenty yards of linen, an hour of a nurse's labor and an hour of a hedge-fund analyst's. In Grand Theft Auto, a stolen ambulance, a dead tourist and a completed heist are commensurable. Each is just a quantity to pile up. The game doesn't need to tell you that its world is ruled by money, because its world has no other register. Even the transgressions are priced. Especially the transgressions.

The game's sense of time is spectacular in the same way. Debord writes about the "pseudo-cyclical" time of consumer society: weekends, holidays and seasonal releases that repeat with the look of renewal and change nothing. Grand Theft Auto runs on exactly this loop. You die, respawn, and the city resets around you, its traffic still flowing and its pedestrians unbothered. Nothing you do leaves a mark except on the counter. The city can absorb any amount of violence and stay itself. That is a description of a game engine. It is also a fair description of the kind of order Debord thought late capitalism had perfected, an order that turns disruption into one more event in the feed.

The Scandal Was the Product

The most Debordian thing about Grand Theft Auto happened outside the game. Before release, its publisher hired Max Clifford, the most notorious tabloid fixer in Britain, to stir up outrage. Stories about a game that rewarded you for killing police and running down pedestrians ran in the papers, and questions about banning it were raised in the House of Lords. The controversy was not an unfortunate side effect of the marketing. It was the marketing. A small top-down game from a studio in Dundee became a national talking point because condemnation had been ordered, paid for and delivered.

In his late Comments on the Society of the Spectacle, Debord describes an "integrated" spectacle, one that no longer stands apart from reality as advertising or ideology but runs through it so thoroughly that every response becomes part of the show. Grand Theft Auto's launch works like a model of this. The game is controversial, and the controversy is a product. The outrage is real, and real outrage is exactly what was bought. A reader who put down the Daily Mail in disgust had already taken part in the campaign. Opposition doesn't threaten the spectacle. It supplies the spectacle with material.

Stuart Hall adds something here that Debord can't, because Hall paid close attention to how British moral panics actually work. In Policing the Crisis, he and his co-authors examined the 1970s scare over "mugging" and showed that the panic had little to do with any measurable rise in crime. Its real work was ideological. It gave a society anxious about economic decline, race and lost authority a figure to fear, and that fear won consent for a harder, more punitive state. The press didn't invent the panic out of nothing. It reproduced the framings of "primary definers" such as police, judges and politicians, and fed them back to the public as common sense. The panic over Grand Theft Auto belongs to the same lineage. It arrived in a Britain still raw from the 1990s scares about "video nasties" and media violence, and in the same year New Labour won power promising to be "tough on crime, tough on the causes of crime." The game offered a familiar folk devil to an argument already in progress.

What Hall shows, and the cynical brilliance of the Clifford campaign confirms, is that the panic and the product serve each other. The game needed a scandal to stand out, and the scandal needed a game to point at. Debord would say both sides were simply spectacle. Hall would push further: the spectacle here does definite political work. It teaches an audience where to look for danger (screens, teenagers, cities) and where not to look (the economy reorganizing itself around them).

The Player Who Won't Play Along

There is a weak spot in Debord's framework, and Grand Theft Auto presses on it. His spectator is fundamentally passive: "the more he contemplates, the less he lives." The spectacle works because it turns people into an audience watching other people live. A video game seems to break that model at once. The player isn't contemplating. The player is driving, shooting, choosing. You could argue that interactivity is precisely what the spectacle couldn't anticipate, a return of the active subject.

Debord would not be persuaded, and he would be partly right. Activity is not the same as freedom. Picking among the options a system has built for you is a richer kind of spectatorship, not its end. Pressing a button to steal a car feels like agency in the same way choosing between forty brands of cereal feels like choice. The menu was written somewhere else.

Still, Hall's model of encoding and decoding keeps this objection from being the last word. Hall argued that a text is encoded with a "preferred" meaning, but audiences decode it from their own position. They may accept the preferred reading, negotiate with it, or read it against its grain. Grand Theft Auto encodes its preferred reading clearly: take the payphone jobs, hit the points target, move to the next city. Players did something else with it, and anyone who played it in 1997 remembers. They ignored the jobs for hours. They tested how long they could survive with four police heads lit up in the corner. They stole an ambulance just to see if the siren worked. They parked a stolen car on a bridge just to listen to the radio. These weren't failures to understand the game. They were negotiated readings, and some of them came close to oppositional ones. Players found the drift inside the scoring system and took it back.

The tension between the two thinkers tells us something real about the game. Debord explains why those pleasures were licensed. The engine permits them, and the score keeps ticking in the background whether you care or not. Hall explains why they still matter. Meaning was never fully in the publisher's hands. The most interesting thing Grand Theft Auto produced in 1997 was not its missions. It was a generation of players discovering that a simulated city could be used against its own instructions. The game is better than its design deserves because it couldn't fully control what players did with it.

Rebellion, Pre-Formatted

If Hall gives the player some agency back, Mark Fisher takes much of it away again, and he does so in a way that updates Debord rather than contradicting him. The Situationists' term for the system swallowing its critics was recuperation: a radical gesture appears, and the culture industry later absorbs it, defangs it and sells it back. Fisher argued that by the late twentieth century this sequence had collapsed into what he called precorporation. Desires and styles of rebellion are now formatted in advance. "Alternative" and "independent" don't name something outside the mainstream. They are the mainstream's most profitable categories.

Grand Theft Auto is precorporation in its purest form. Its transgression was never captured, because it was never free in the first place. It was designed, packaged and publicized as transgression from the start. The car-jacking, the cop-killing and the Kill Frenzies weren't a counterculture that the market later found. They were a market segment that a publicist then dressed up as counterculture. Playing it felt like getting away with something. That feeling is what you paid for.

The game's humor fits Fisher's account just as well. Grand Theft Auto is soaked in irony. Its radio stations parody American genres, its cities are lampoons of New York, Miami and San Francisco, and its tone constantly winks to tell you none of this is serious. That irony is often funny, and the radio especially is a real pleasure. It also has a function. Fisher, following Žižek, saw ironic distance as the default posture of capitalist realism. We know the system is absurd, we laugh at it, and we keep doing exactly what it asks. Fisher called this reflexive impotence. Knowingness doesn't loosen the grip. It makes the grip comfortable. The player of Grand Theft Auto gets to wreck the city and feel above the wrecking, to rack up points and sneer at the scoreboard, all at once.

It matters that this was made in 1997, in Britain, the year Fisher would later see as the moment capitalist realism stopped being a program and became the atmosphere. Thatcher's "there is no alternative" had been inherited, rebranded and made cool. The America that DMA built is a Scottish studio's fantasy assembled from crime films and cop shows, and in it crime is the only way to have a relationship with the city at all. You can't organize Liberty City, change it, or even live in it. You can only drive through it and take things. Fisher's famous line, that it is easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism, has an exact equivalent here: it is easier to blow up the city than to imagine it arranged any other way.

A Brilliant Accident, Unevenly Built

None of this makes Grand Theft Auto a bad game. As a work, it deserves a lot of credit, and it's worth separating what it does well from what it represents. Its central achievement is genuine and influential: a city that runs as a system rather than a set of corridors. Traffic flows whether you watch it or not. Police respond in escalating waves. Pedestrians scatter, cars pile up at junctions, and a small mistake at an intersection can grow into a five-minute chase across half the map. The best moments are not written. They emerge, and that emergent quality is why the game still feels alive in a way many of its more polished contemporaries don't. The camera that zooms out as you speed up is a quietly brilliant idea. The radio, which made a car feel like a place you lived in rather than just a vehicle, became the franchise's signature for good reason.

The game is also rough in ways that go beyond the technical limits of its era. The top-down view makes high speed a guessing game, because you can rarely see far enough ahead to react. The handling is twitchy and unforgiving. Progress is saved only between levels, so one bad crash can wipe out an hour of work. That makes the points target feel less like a goal than a grind, especially since the missions are mostly variations on the same few errands: deliver this, kill him, get there before the timer runs out. The three cities share too much of the same grammar to feel like truly different places.

The deeper problem is that the game stumbles onto a form that could say something real about cities, about who moves through them, who polices them and who gets to call them home, and then does almost nothing with it. Its irony stands in for a point of view. A game this close to the shape of the dérive could have made drifting mean something. Instead it settles for making it pay. The result is an important game and a frequently delightful one, but not a profound one. Its vision is sharper than its execution, and its execution is sharper than its ideas.

The Map Before the Territory

It's impossible to play the original Grand Theft Auto now without seeing the empire it became. The series grew into one of the most profitable entertainment properties ever made. Its online mode turned the old points counter into a real economy: players can spend actual money on bundles of in-game cash. The joke at the heart of the 1997 game, that every act is just a number to accumulate, stopped being a joke and became a business model. The game that once scored your crimes now sells you the score. Debord could hardly have designed a cleaner illustration of the spectacle as capital accumulated to the point where it becomes image.

That is what gives the first game its odd, ghostly charge, and here Fisher's idea of hauntology fits. Fisher was drawn to cultural artifacts haunted by futures that never arrived: the experimental promise of postwar modernism, or the strange openness of early electronic music, before the market closed those possibilities off. The original Grand Theft Auto is a minor artifact of that kind. Played today, its crudeness reads almost like candor. The city is still visibly a map. The score is still visibly a score, sitting in the corner and declaring its logic out loud. Later entries would bury that logic under photorealism, celebrity voice acting and cinematic missions. The spectacle would become so immersive you could forget you were looking at it. In 1997 you couldn't forget, because the game kept showing you the diagram.

So the game is worth returning to, not as a classic in the usual sense, but as an x-ray. It shows the bones of something that later grew skin. For a short time, players could drift through a cartoon city and feel, half-consciously, the strangeness of a world where every act of freedom came with a price tag already attached. The game didn't understand what it had shown them. It hardly needed to. Debord's point was always that the spectacle doesn't hide its workings out of shame. It shows them, and it bets that we'll keep playing anyway. We did.
Mini Review: Grand Theft Auto shows you its city from above, the way a planner sees it, and lets you drift through it, which was once a radical Situationist gesture. Then it scores everything. Theft, chaos and errands all become points, so even rebellion has a price tag. The tabloid outrage was paid for as marketing, and the irony comes prepackaged. Players still found ways to wander against the game’s instructions. It’s a thrilling, crude, important game whose vision outruns its ideas.