If you came to it blind you might think it was ok, but given how much worse the story mode is than the previous game, I think it's ok to call it shit. There are also problems of balance, eg you can hit an opponent with 3 finishers and they'll kick out, but once they hit you one, you're dead.

Mediocre? Greatest of all time? This is the one with Jerry Lynn, so it's the only one I'll rank.