Groundbreaking in terms of production quality, strategic diversity, environment reactivity, general attention to detail and tabletop loyalty. The over-arching story is a jumbled mess of cliches cowering behind (sometimes) good dialogue. The characters and races are cringe. The D&D ruleset hasn't improved. Build diversity is meh (partly for lack of good tactic-defining items), multiclass is a low-reward chore, and the per-rest mechanic is ruinous. Still manages to be amazing, despite its flaws.

Dropped. May revisit in the future. Good: Every NPC dialogue is voiced and good grafix. Bad: Every models looks prestine... samey doll like faces. Exploration & combat is tedious. Overwhelming amount of skills at the start, and equipment benefits are vague (Incentivize internet tutorials). Dialogue: Quantity doesnt mean quality... lots of flowery prose. A heavy dependency on dialogue for immersion. If the writing style isnt for you. Immersion is broken.

Whelp. Here we are. The perfect D&D game. It does such a great job of combining tabletop realism, AAA scope, and wonderful writing.

It's no hyperbole, it really is one of the best games ever made. The only thing holding back that final point is that it's still pretty buggy

Very seldom does a game live up to the ideal perfection within a genre. Baldur's Gate 3 does exactly that. The world feels completely alive, the story is incredibly compelling, and the characters are well rounded. Dozens of hours of side quests, exploration, and countless unique encounters leave nothing to be desired. This title truly does live up to every single promise it made during development. One of the greatest games ever made on any platform.

3 things I hate about this game: UI, Combat mechanics, Camera.

One of the best games ever made.

#1 Best by Average Percentile on Criticker

Didn’t believe I could experience these old thrills again. It’svthere. It’s magic, adventure, changing seamlessly between the big events and small characters. It’s long, but it was the first game in years, where I actually wanted to stay a bit longer.

Genuinely mean it when I say the biggest flaw is the D&D rules. There is a reason the rules go to lvl 20 and this game stops at 12. WotC did a terrible job balancing 5E, Larian did a great job given the 5E constraints. I really enjoy the humor the writers at Larian have. Production quality is immaculate. Super horny, both in a good and bad way.

Really worth playing more slowly in multiplayer with a group of friends, adding back a little of the D&D chaotic feel that is lost by controlling all 4 characters in single player mode. Overall it is a friendly AAA game, yet still really enjoyable.

The combat of BG3 is not horribly interesting until you reach act 3 when the encounters play more with gimmicks. A lot of classes tend to overlap on utility to the point spell pools look samey and you're often using the same thing across characters. The plot? It's... mediocre. The companions are a mixed bag in terms of execution. For example, Astarion ends off on a strong note but Gale and Wyll are boring as fuck and half-assed. But it has enough personality and flair to keep me invested

Ultimate translation of pen & paper to the screen! Love how this game dares you to break it, though it still works a bit too often. Ample opportunity to miss out on content makes for excellent replay value. What the hell's wrong with the "character editor", though? Two body types and a couple of faces, but i can give myself an adjustable amount of vitiligo, which literally NOBODY in this game has?! How weirdly specific. Anyway, i can get people to run around butt naked, so who am i to complain?

Baldur's Gate 3 is now my favorite RPG of all time. D&D is special to me and this game delivered that the best imo. Characters and the stories are incredible, this game has made me emotional and sad to happy and ecstatic with in a short amount of time. BG3 gives a perfect blend of strategy and difficulty with a lot of new game plus motives to try every class and race. If I could play one game for the rest of my life it'll be BG3. Amazing job Larian Studios.

Maybe some DLC could bump this up to a 9 or even a 10.