Condemned 2: Bloodshot

I STILL get to hit hobos with pipes, I'm in like Flynn baby.

I fucking love this game... until it goes all dumb-brain and gives you a sonic-boom voice

This has higher highs and lower lows than the first. The combat and save system are much better. I find it scarier than the first because it leans into the psychological horror quicker, but perhaps the first had a slightly better atmosphere because you drown in that shit. But they're comparable. The final plot reveal is rightfully hated by a lot of people, though despite that, the game did set up a Condemned 3 in an interesting way. - Full Review

i remember being disappointed and not even scared

They jumped the shark. Nicer to control than the first, it just doesn't have the same oppressive atmosphere.