>
The Ten Most Polarizing Games of the 2000s

The Ten Most Polarizing Games of the 2000s

Ahh... the 2000s! Remember them? The first decade of the 21st century was a transformative decade for video gaming, marking its leap from niche hobby to mainstream entertainment. We saw the rise of powerful home consoles, such as the PlayStation 2, Xbox, and GameCube, followed by the Xbox 360, PlayStation 3, and Wii, and this rapid innovation defined a new era of 3D graphics, cinematic storytelling, and online connectivity.
And publishers made great use of their new hardware, releasing instant classics like Grand Theft Auto III (2001), The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker (2002), Halo 2 (2004), Bioshock (2007), and Mass Effect (2007). But not every game was universally loved. Just like anything else, games have the power to be deeply divisive. We've run the numbers at Criticker, and have found the ten most polarizing games of the 2000s. Do you remember any of these? Or, perhaps still play them?
How was this calculated?
For every film with at a certain number of ratings, we calculate the percentage of people who loved it (percentle greater than 75%) and hated it (less than 25%). The "contentiousness" score is the lower of those two percentiles.
Consider the most contentious possible scenario -- an equal number love and hate it, with nobody in between. That would be 50% - 0% - 50%, for a score of "50". Let's say another film has a "love/ambivalence/hate" ratio of "38/30/32". That gets a score of 32: still extremely polarizing!
But a movie that almost everyone hates? Let's say a breakdown of 4/35/61. That's a score of just 4, which means it's not very contentious at all.
#10. Syberia
20% High
"A straightforward adventure with "puzzles" and "eccentric characters" of the sort fans of the genre know well, delivered a tad easily and slowly, for better or worse. Where it shines is in the settings, as each stop along the way takes you to a new, attentively-drawn fantasy of a lonely, forgotten little world that might have been. Is the writing really as evocative as the art? Well, maybe not, but it does give reason enough to keep following along and see what you're after." - Heliophage
23.64% Low
"Shockingly beautiful even now in the mid '20s -- like an 0.7 on the RE Remake scale. The writing and voice acting and the punishingly slow movement across a ton of rather long screens did not hold up nearly as well." - Sweekoden
20% High
"The best fighting game of the PS3/360 era? Definitely in contention, at least in my opinion." - vv238
30% Low
"I'll stick to Mortal Kombat" - jschlanksy
22.49% High
"Best FF ever, mostly thanks to throwing away boring outdated fighting system from previous versions." - edkrak
20.12% Low
"Never really got into this one, though it seems to be a fan favourite in recent years. The level progression made absolutely no sense, and in general was far to grindy for its own good. Neither the story nor the characters impressed me either. I liked the open world though, and the ability to skip cutscenes was a welcome addition." - Daigoro
20.69% High
"Godfather of Competitive Multiplayer FPS and Tactical FPS Combat genres. A game-changer! 1.4 >= 1.6 > Source" - KeyUtkan
24.52% Low
"Rating this game would be like rating at least 3 different games because of the major patches Valve dropped. 1.4 was my favorite, but 1.6 was better than CS: Source. This isn't for anyone other than tactical shooting purists but for those people, this is something akin to a temple." - vv238
#6. Peggle
22.95% High
"Games that rely more on pure luck than actual skill often tend to drive me crazy, and Peggle is no exception in that department. The difference is Peggle maintains some kind of irresistible addictiveness and I really have no clue why. It might be the bright rainbows or the enthusiastic sound effects whenever you do something totally awesome" - Brambon
21.31% Low
"I could see playing this if I got super bored or as a joke with friends but there isn't a whole lot to it, feels like a flash game I would have played in the early 2000's. It can be fun for a few levels." - Tanklin13
22.75% High
"they somehow topped COD4. MAP DESIGN! so important to a good competitive shooter. maps like Highrise still unsurpassed today." - SkeebosRibShack
21.57% Low
"A relatively fun thing to play, but it felt a little like a DLC to the first Modern Warfare, rather than a new game that deserves to be bought for €60. Plus, it's the first step in the descent of the once awesome Call of Duty franchise into the wretched remains of its former self that it is now." - OliVDB5590
21.92% High
"There's a reason that this is often called an underrated gem if you google search. It's wonky in some of the mechanics, but it's one of those games where the flaws don't seem to weigh down the game that much. These problems might be more noticeable in something else. But yeah, fun action and of course as other fans have already said, the dialogue choices mattered, which is a big deal. I unabashedly loved this game when I played it back in '10." - Obdurate
27.4% Low
"Was hoping for a Fallout New Vegas type game but it turns out all that boring talking is completely pointless because they just throw you into a bullet sponge shootout regardless. Even the stealth elements are entirely pointless since it's guaranteed to fall into a gunfight no matter what." - li0li
22% High
"My most played game of all time. There is some magic hear that slowly dwindled with waning dev support and the explosion of crate/key lootbox systems. Oh to be back in the halcyon days of the Gold Rush Update era." - CMonster
23.25% Low
"Not for me, some fun can be had but yeah just not really for me." - TheEscapist
24.49% High
"With it's razor sharp sense of humor and legendary graphics. Conker's Bad Fur Day is an unmatched success for RAREWare. It may not be as freeing as Banjo, but the story is well worth the journey and the game play features enough extras to go back to for years to come." - mwestcott
23.47% Low
"The difficulty was wildly uneven in frustrating ways, to the point of souring the whole thing in my mind. I still am amused by bits of it, though." - Daisoujou
29.49% High
"To this day still the king of MMORPG. At its peak players were astoundingly numerous. Like most of the genre grinding becomes tedious but starting a guild with 20 of your friends that you know the real world and fucking sucking at everything but having a blast is priceless." - hellboy76
30.29% Low
"I played about 20 minutes of this on someone else's account in reality, but listened to enough stupid conversations about it circa 2006-2008 to feel justified in ranking it." - overrated